
Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez emailed supporters this week “to ask you to sign up to volunteer for whatever comes next for us. Whether it’s organizing to pass necessary legislation … or whether it’s a political campaign.”
The subtext is barely submerged. She’s stoking anticipation for a 2028 campaign, either for president or for U.S. Senator from New York. She certainly doesn’t need volunteers to hold down her cobalt blue Bronx-and-Queens U.S. House district.
Before she makes such a consequential decision, she should consider the cautionary tale of Senator Chris Van Hollen.
Of course, if the internet-savvy, groundbreaking democratic socialist wants to serve as president or senator, she should pursue it, no matter what some jackass pundit has to say. But in her own words, her ambition is not “a title or a seat” but “to change this country. Presidents come and go … elected officials come and go, but single-payer health care is forever, a living wage is forever, workers’ rights are forever.” Whether a run for higher office is the best way for the soon-to-be fifth-term representative to achieve those goals is worth considering.
Van Hollen’s ambitions have not been stated so plainly. But his career arc is well known. As The New York Times recapped, after 14 years in the U.S. House and earning a spot on Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s leadership team, he “was seen as a potential future speaker in the House, but that prospect had seemed far off given Ms. Pelosi’s hold on the office. When Barbara Mikulski of Baltimore was set to retire from the Senate in 2016, he sought her seat and won.”
But 10 years in the Senate has not given him a legacy-defining legislative achievement, let alone Ocasio-Cortez levels of fame and acclaim, and he began itching for even higher office. In June, he said he was “kicking the tires” on a presidential run. Then—as some senators and senators-elect grew agitated over the possibility of stagnant leadership—the 67-year-old from affluent Montgomery County, Maryland abruptly switched to running for Senate Majority Leader against the current Minority Leader Chuck Schumer.
Maybe Van Hollen miraculously prevails when the Senate Democratic Caucus votes on December 1, but since announcing on November 12 and getting four endorsements the following day, he’s picked up only one additional name—Senator Elissa Slotkin, who offered a tepid endorsement yesterday. Most telling, he has no chorus of colleagues joining his call to use the December 11 deadline to keep the government open as a bargaining chip to cut off Iran War funds. Van Hollen cites his shutdown gambit as a key difference between him and Schumer. Still, it may well push senators into Schumer’s camp, since senators typically don’t want their leader pressuring them into dicey stratagems.
With the caveat that miracles are possible, Van Hollen’s story is a cautionary tale. He climbed into the House leadership and was poised to play a more influential role. Lacking the patience to wait for Pelosi’s retirement, he scurried upward on the electoral ladder. But that proved to be a superficial advancement. Sure, Senators have more individual power than the average Representative—dramatically so when they are in the minority and can block legislation and nominations—but it is power more easily wielded to stymie rather than to advance. Unsatisfied with Senate membership itself, Van Hollen’s eye wandered toward a higher, harder-to-attain post.
If Ocasio-Cortez leveraged her national fame to run for president or senator, she would not sacrifice a House leadership position, but she would risk her seat. Higher office isn’t hers for the taking. In the Real Clear Politics average of 2028 presidential primary polls, she is at 14 percent. That puts her squarely in the running; she’s not far from the leader, former Vice President Kamala Harris, at 16.5 percent. But it’s not nearly enough to feel confident. And even if she somehow won the Democratic nomination for president in 2028, her Decision Desk HQ national favorability average—36 percent, four points less than her unfavorability—suggests the general election would also be uncertain. (Other established Republican politicians, like Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, have worse favorability ratings, but fresher GOP faces may emerge with less baggage and fewer ties to Donald Trump.)
The Senate is an easier shot, but not a layup. Yes, polls show that in a primary, Ocasio-Cortez would trounce the incumbent New Yorker up for re-election: the septuagenarian, almost-Majority Leader Schumer. But if the 76-year-old doesn’t run, she’ll face younger opponents—Politico reports that Representatives Pat Ryan and Ritchie Torres may be in the mix. A September Quinnipiac poll shows her with near-universal favorability among New York Democrats, but with a 41 percent favorability among likely voters in the general electorate. That’s five points better than her statewide unfavorability, though she is underwater in the suburbs and upstate where she’s never had to compete for votes. Would she be the favorite in the primary and the general across a huge, diverse state? Yes, but hardly a lock.
Running for Senate may be a mild risk, but why take it? She is a lock to keep her House district, maybe for the rest of her working life. At just 37, with eight years in the House, she’s already in the middle of the pack in terms of seniority. As older members retire and younger politicians enter the House, she will eventually find it easier to earn committee chair and leadership positions, and then have decades to wield that power.
Most importantly, she already has what most other politicians crave: a national platform, near-universal name recognition, tons of online access to campaign cash, and a natural charisma that makes political communication look easy. She already has the largest social media following in the House, by millions, and more than anyone in the Senate save for her mentor, the 85-year-old Bernie Sanders, whose age she won’t reach until 2069. She cannot choose what legislation moves through the House, but her pronouncements carry great weight within the progressive movement. Her endorsement and small-donor network—if not determinative—can alter the dynamics of Democratic primaries. She doesn’t need a freshman backbench seat in the U.S. Senate to draw attention.
The power of the presidency is exponentially greater than any legislative seat. If she wants it, and isn’t precious about clinging to her House seat, then sure: Go big or go home.
Yet Ocasio-Cortez’s stated criterion is not “a title or a seat” but “to change this country.” Currently, she has more power than many House members to change the country, and that clout will likely grow the longer she stays in the House. Running for president or senator risks losing that power. The presidency’s unequaled power may be worth that risk. But for someone as powerful as Ocasio-Cortez, and with more interest in legislating than filibustering, the Senate doesn’t offer enough of an upgrade to justify risking a secure House seat.
Van Hollen’s impatience led him to quit a promising House career. His senatorial frustrations should at least factor in as Ocasio-Cortez weighs her biggest career decision.
The post AOC Should Consider the Cautionary Tale of Van Hollen appeared first on Washington Monthly.