A growing number of House Democrats say they’re open to using their new majority to impeach President Donald Trump — but they’re concerned that a rush job could backfire.
After two attempts to remove the president during the first Trump administration, many members are heeding advice from colleagues who led those previous battles and say a third attempt must be methodical or risk playing into the weakened president’s hands.
“I think Donald Trump would love us to organize a campaign of impeachment against him right now because he thinks that's his last hope for rallying the dwindling MAGA base at this point,” said Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), who is poised to lead the House Judiciary Committee next year and ran the impeachment trial against Trump over the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol.
Indeed, Trump has previously declared that his first two impeachments benefited him politically and said recently he would welcome the prospect of a third.
“I think it would destroy the Democrat Party if they did that, because it would be impeachment for no reason,” he said to reporters a day after the GOP’s midterm drubbing. “For what? For having a successful country?”
Trump’s comment hits on another fundamental dilemma for Democrats: What, precisely, would a new round of impeachment articles against Trump say? While Democrats have accused him of wide-ranging corruption — self-enrichment, accepting foreign gifts, granting pay-for-play pardons, abusing power to target his enemies and launching an illegal war in Iran — there is no consensus about what charges a Democratic House would level, or what type of investigation would precede formal action.
Interviews with 14 House Democrats from across the ideological spectrum reveal a desire to proceed with varying degrees of caution as party leaders plot the next two years in power ahead of the next presidential election, when Trump will be term-limited out of office anyway.
Some Democrats say the chamber should prioritize policy fights rather than impeachment — including Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) who led the now-defunct Jan. 6 committee that concluded Trump presented a unique danger to the republic.
“Impeachment is not a priority for me,” said Thompson, the likely next chair of the Homeland Security committee. “If other members file a resolution and it gets to the floor, I'll vote for it.”
Many Democrats worry that dragging the country through divisive and time-consuming impeachment proceedings could prove futile if they don’t first lay the groundwork to persuade the public that such an exercise is necessary.
And even a perfectly executed process would run into a math problem: It takes two-thirds of the Senate to convict a president in an impeachment trial, meaning Democrats would need at least 11 Republicans to join them for a conviction — a threshold they failed to clear even in the days after the Jan. 6 riot.
Raskin noted the tricky “constitutional arithmetic,” and he’s not alone.
“Is the Senate going to convict? You need to weigh that in and whether to proceed,” said Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), who served with Thompson and Raskin on the Jan. 6 committee. She was also an impeachment manager in 2020, when Democrats sought to remove Trump on grounds he threatened to withhold foreign aid to Ukraine unless president Volodymyr Zelenskyy agreed to investigate his political enemies.
“I think we need a national conversation,” Lofgren added.
Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-N.Y.) was even more blunt: “No,” he said when asked whether the House should impeach Trump. “I'm a former prosecutor. You don't indict somebody if you don't think you can convict.”
Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, who is expected to be speaker in January and was himself a manager in the Ukraine-related impeachment trial, has so far taken a cautious approach to the issue.
“I haven't had a single member of the House Democratic Caucus talk to me about impeachment,” Jeffries said a day after the midterms. “We've been relentlessly focused on affordability and on accountability.”
When asked Thursday if Trump has committed impeachable offenses, Jeffries dodged: “As I've repeatedly indicated, we haven't ruled anything in. We haven't ruled anything out. We're going to follow the facts. We're going to apply the law. We're going to be guided by the Constitution, and we're going to let the chips fall where they may.”
Jeffries’ approach tracks closely with that of his predecessor Nancy Pelosi, who as speaker resisted early pressure from Democrats to rush toward impeachment after they took the majority in 2019. Though some members were then eager to impeach Trump over allegations stemming from the investigation of his contacts with Russia, Pelosi insisted that the chamber wait to build a clear case to the public that impeachment was warranted.
Her calculus changed when a whistleblower informed Congress about Trump’s dealings with Zelenskyy. Some Democratic lawmakers are convinced that Trump’s penchant for escalation against his adversaries could give them fresh fodder for impeachment in the next Congress.
“We'll see what the next two years bring in terms of what Trump does,” said Rep. Yassamin Ansari (D-Ariz.) in an interview. “Because I also do worry that he's going to get more and more desperate and more and more volatile, and who knows what actions he may take that just become impossible to ignore when it comes to impeachment.”
But Ansari also acknowledged the potential for a strategic blunder in rushing headlong into the process: “I am torn on it. I believe that he should be impeached, but I also hear the concerns of colleagues, especially ones who were here and have been through that. That perhaps that would suck the oxygen in a way that is not the most effective.”
Another deterrent for Democrats: A quick impeachment in the House would trigger a Senate trial that would grind Washington to a halt, just as Democrats are attempting to make good on their promises to prioritize affordability for Americans. Presidential impeachments instantly displace other Senate business and even typically requires the chief justice of the Supreme Court to preside.
At the same time, Democratic leaders will also have to deal with a faction that remains driven to impeach Trump quickly, who argue that slow-walking proceedings in the face of impeachable offenses would be risky in a different way.
“It's setting a dangerous precedent when people [are] like, ‘no, it's a distraction.’ What are you talking about?” said Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.), who famously rankled party leaders by declaring her intent to “impeach the motherfucker” just days after taking office in 2019. “This won't be the last president that runs businesses out of the Oval Office.”
Rep. Suhas Subramanyam (D-Va.) also said Democrats shouldn’t be afraid to stand their ground: “If there is something that is worthy of impeachment, we should have impeachment, even if it's bad politics.”
Democrats also need to be attuned to voters who may want to see the party hold Trump accountable, said Rep. Becca Balint (D-Vt.), while noting she would vote for an impeachment resolution on the floor.
“There's definitely a core of our base that wants revenge and vengeance, right? And there's another group, actually, that just wants to make sure that the Constitution will hold, and that they feel like if [Trump] is allowed to get away with this without a third impeachment, then what does that say about the system?” she said in an interview.
Ultimately, Rep. Jason Crow (D-Colo.), who served as a manager in Trump’s first trial, said it was important to remember that impeachment is just one option for holding the president accountable.
“Impeachment has taken on this almost mythical place in American culture because people know about it. But it's a tool. It's not an end in and of itself,” he said. “I've done it before … and if I thought that was appropriate, I would do it again. But right now, we have to see what type of coalition we can put together.”