JMSC Finds Alan D. Clemmons Not Qualified for Horry County Master-in-Equity – Clemons wrote the controversial MBACC TDF Legislation

Posted

Nov 19, 2026 · https://x.com/myrtlebeachnews

The state’s judicial screening panel on Thursday found Horry County Master-in-Equity Alan D. Clemmons not qualified to keep the bench he has held since 2022.

We have written exclusively on Alan D. Clemmons, the controversial judge who once served as a S.C. State Representative from Horry County. As a State Rep. Clemmons wrote the legislation known as the TDF for the Myrtle Beach Area Chamber of Commerce. The 1% tax was passed without a voter referendum. $22,000 in sequentially marked cashiers checks were handed to politicians by former MBACC President Brad Dean and others getting the bill passed.

The South Carolina Judicial Merit Selection Commission (JMSC) listed Clemmons, a former Myrtle Beach state representative, as “Not Qualified” in its report on master-in-equity candidates. He was the only master-in-equity candidate on that page of the report to be found unqualified. Every other sitting master-in-equity seeking a new term, from Beaufort to York County, was found qualified.

The finding is a sharp reversal. Clemmons once chaired the very commission that has now rejected him. His current six-year term expires July 31, 2027.

The master-in-equity runs Horry County’s Equity Court, a division of circuit court that hears non-jury matters referred by circuit judges. Most of that docket is mortgage foreclosures and other property cases, including the county’s foreclosure sales.

What the JMSC found

Of nine master-in-equity candidates on the report page, eight were found qualified. Clemmons, the only Horry County candidate, was the lone exception.

CountyCandidateFinding
HorryAlan D. Clemmons, Myrtle BeachNot Qualified
BeaufortJames J. Wegmann, BeaufortQualified
CalhounMartin R. Banks, CayceQualified
GreenvilleCharles B. Simmons Jr., GreenvilleQualified
OrangeburgRussell A. Blanchard IV, OrangeburgQualified
OrangeburgEdgar W. Dickson, OrangeburgQualified
RichlandStephanie N. Lawrence, ColumbiaQualified
SpartanburgShannon M. Phillips, InmanQualified
YorkTeasa Kay Weaver, YorkQualified

Source: JMSC findings page provided by the publisher, Nov. 19, 2026. The same page shows Administrative Law Court Seat 2 candidate Samuel L. Johnson and three active retired circuit judges (J. Cordell Maddox Jr., Edward W. Miller and Clifton Newman) found qualified.

The public hearings for this screening cycle were set to begin Nov. 16, 2026. Clemmons was the only candidate listed for the Horry County seat.

Who is Alan Clemmons

Clemmons is a Myrtle Beach native and real estate attorney who spent 18 years in the S.C. House before becoming a judge.

  • Legislator, 2002–2020. Republican, House District 107 (Myrtle Beach and the Grand Strand). Chaired the House Rules Committee and sat on Ways and Means (AP).
  • JMSC insider. Served on the Judicial Merit Selection Commission from 2008, including terms as vice chairman and as chairman (SC Legislature).
  • Abrupt resignation, July 17, 2020. He quit about five weeks after winning his GOP primary over Case Brittain, citing his business (Ballotpedia). Earlier that year he had sought, and did not get, the Myrtle Beach city attorney and Horry County administrator jobs.
  • Master-in-Equity, 2022–present. After sitting out the required year, he applied for the Horry County seat. The JMSC rated him qualified in 2021, but he was the lowest-rated of three candidates in S.C. Bar reports (Grand Strand Daily). The Horry County delegation nominated him anyway, and Gov. Henry McMaster appointed him. He took the bench Feb. 28, 2022 (Horry County).

That 2021–22 selection drew sharp criticism. The Nerve noted that three of the six lawmakers then on the JMSC were part of the Horry delegation Clemmons had just left.

What happens next

Under state law, a not-qualified finding ends Clemmons’ path to a new term: he can serve out his current term, which ends July 31, 2027, and no longer.

  • Binding finding. “No person found not qualified by the commission may be appointed to the office of master-in-equity” (S.C. Code § 2-19-110).
  • Incumbents. An incumbent found not qualified is not put forward again and “shall cease serving” when the current term expires (§ 2-19-80(C)(1)).
  • Reopened seat. The commission must screen new candidates as though the seat had no incumbent (§ 2-19-80(C)(2)).
  • Selection. The JMSC sends qualified names to the Horry County legislative delegation, which nominates one to the governor for appointment.
  • Reasons on the record. The JMSC must report “the particular reasons” a candidate was found not qualified (§ 2-19-80(D)). Those reasons will appear in its written report to the General Assembly.

The JMSC scores candidates on nine criteria: constitutional qualifications, ethical fitness, professional and academic ability, character, reputation, physical health, mental stability, experience and judicial temperament. It now has 12 members, six of them legislators. Rules summarized from the JMSC Policies and Procedures manual.

Sources

Alan D. Clemmons – JMSC findings page (photo provided by publisher), Nov. 19, 2026

Alan D. Clemmons – JMSC: Judicial vacancies release, July 20, 2026

Alan D. Clemmons – JMSC: Candidates and hearings release, Aug. 24, 2026

Alan D. Clemmons – JMSC Policies and Procedures manual

Alan D. Clemmons – Horry County Master-in-Equity office

Alan D. Clemmons – SC Legislature member page

Alan D. Clemmons – AP via Washington Times, July 19, 2020

Alan D. Clemmons – Ballotpedia

Alan D. Clemmons – Grand Strand Daily

Alan D. Clemmons – The Nerve via Index-Journal

News, Editors Choice